Went to my uncles cabin in the woods for a few days to relax, he's got the box set of the show and decided to give it a rewatch, was a pretty big fan in college. Got through like 3 episodes and shut it off.
Yes, Whedon is a creepy and maybe knowing that affecting my judgment, but honestly does feel like I'm noticing things my younger brain didn't. A lot of the dialog seems overwritten, some of the "quirky" shit the characters do comes off more obnoxious than endearing, also the story is giving me weird AnCap vibes. I mean yeah the Alliance clearly is pretty evil but we never get much explanation as to what the Brown Coats political program is, why did they want to succeed? Them being confederate coded sure as shit doesn't help.
Also, it almost leans TOO much into the whole western asethic sometimes, to the point I find it unbelievable. Okay, sure, humanity hastily colonized some planets and now some have regressed into SciFi Deadwood, I can dig that. But like, people on horses with cowboy hats seems a bit too comic for me.
Idk, just some random observations.
Edit: oh yeah and the intro song fucking sucks. That was something I thought even back when I liked the show.
Yeah, I knew that from the beginning but kinda wrote it off as part of the whole western thing, since having a Southern Vet of the civil war who's all bitter about losing is a bit of a trope in that genre. Probably would have worked better if the lore of the show did a better job of explaining what their whole deal was rather ran just being generic "underdogs", so the Confederate coding just comes off as problematic.
I prefer the similar plot of Farscape, but instead of space confederates being the protagonists, it's a bunch of minority alien convicts fighting a colonial empire and instigating revolution. Which is really just the plot of basically every space thing since Star Wars.
It's the Fargate, with an F
That's my problem with how little is shown of the Alliance, making a faction all grey all day is not a substitute for showing me why it's bad
I mean, they were trying to genetically engineer psycho super soldiers using kidnapped girls, and had creepy CIA looking dudes with radiations death sticks. So they're probably pretty evil, but the only reason the Browncoats give for trying to succeed from them is "muh big guberment trying to get in our business". Get in your business for what? Cuz the guys who inspired you didn't like the guberment getting in their business about owning slaves. Didn't even mention the death stick secret police.
Yeah, the Alliance is basically supposed to be cyberpunk white dude China and built from a bunch of classic "the US literally did/tried to do this and the Soviets verifiably did not, but we're gonna write it as the Soviets doing it" tropes, while the secessionists were just like "yeah I can't handle all their rules you know *licks lips inappropriately* had to come out here for some real freedom you know *lips licks some more, for longer* heh heh heh you know what I'm talking about," Heinleinian (how the fuck is "Heinleinian" an actual word that spellcheck accepts) frontiersmen.
"a civil war" is not the same as "the civil war"
Yeah this is like saying paradise lost is confederate apoligia