Please not with the grandiose promises again hello games, not again.
this post was submitted on 11 Dec 2023
90 points (92.5% liked)
Games
16742 readers
842 users here now
Video game news oriented community. No NanoUFO is not a bot :)
Posts.
- News oriented content (general reviews, previews or retrospectives allowed).
- Broad discussion posts (preferably not only about a specific game).
- No humor/memes etc..
- No affiliate links
- No advertising.
- No clickbait, editorialized, sensational titles. State the game in question in the title. No all caps.
- No self promotion.
- No duplicate posts, newer post will be deleted unless there is more discussion in one of the posts.
- No politics.
Comments.
- No personal attacks.
- Obey instance rules.
- No low effort comments(one or two words, emoji etc..)
- Please use spoiler tags for spoilers.
My goal is just to have a community where people can go and see what new game news is out for the day and comment on it.
Other communities:
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
Right? You'd think he'd wise up lmao
They had a solid redemption arc post-release from No Man's Sky. Sean Murray may be riding that high and lost track of the lesson he should've learned, which is scary for them, since he himself claims in the article that Light No Fire is a much more difficult premise to make than No Man's Sky, and they only pulled that off after an incredibly extended development cycle, and just by the skin of their teeth.
And if Sean is saying it's much harder, than the reality is likely terrifying.
Sean Murray may be riding that high and lost track of the lesson he should’ve learned
Oh hell no. He learned his lesson very well, that being that you can lie through your teeth, sell unfinished garbage, spend a decade implementing a fraction of what you promised, and become one of the most beloved studios in the business as a result. He's doing the same thing again because it worked like magic the first time.
The "but the game is good now" people are the ones who showed him he can do exactly the same thing again without any serious repercussions.
load more comments
(1 replies)
It worked the first time. Why would he?
Yeah. I don’t know why devs talk about features of a game that is years out. Bums me out to hear about Witcher 4, as a massive Witcher fan. Like, why are you hyping this game up? Do you not remember CP2077 release? Do they not remember NMS release?
Promise of what though? Boring "gameplay"?
STOP. SHUT UP. DO NOT MAKE HUGE CLAIMS ABOUT WHAT THIS GAME WILL BE. Please learn from your mistakes.
What mistakes? They got rich with No Mans Sky.
-
Overpromise
-
Sell
-
Shut the fuck up during the outrage
-
Update game
Seemed like a winning formula for them.
They also created reputation for themselves full releasing incomplete games and then only fixing it years later.
So now gamers will learn. Don't buy that games until about 4 to 5 years after release.
load more comments
(2 replies)
Is that really a huge claim though? A big mountain you can climb over isn't particularly exciting in the current realm of technical possibilities.
He's just good at making it sound cool, I guess.
It's both a huge claim and an unimportant one, and that's why it's a problem.
Claiming you have "taller than Mt. Everest" mountains in your game is easily verifiable, and a ton of work. Because you need a map that fits a mountain that size, and need to do all the artwork, make it an interesting place to be. It's not impossible, just a lot of work.
At the same time, it's not very important. When I'm looking for a next game, I don't care how high the mountains are. I want an interesting place. Skyrims High Hrotgar for example is an interesting place with an interesting story. It felt very high and a long walk (7000 steps), but it probably pales in comparison to Mt. Everest.
So promise us a great story, interesting characters, or challenging gameplay. A good game, not a technical masterpiece that will be empty.
Someone on that other site did the math and conclusively calculated that High Hrothgar is about 2000ft above sea level.
That's a decent hill
Yeah, that's a fair point. It would be more exciting if it wasn't procedurally generated, and that those mountaintops actually have something important to the gameplay or story explicitely placed there.
Then it would at least make a bit more sense to talk about how climbable those huge mountains are.
load more comments
(1 replies)
I see Sean Murray has learned nothing from the No Man's Sky hype cycle. I don't want grandiose promises about the scope and scale of the world, I want to know what exactly I'll be doing in it. They're promising role-playing depth, but the whole part about "building, survival, and exploration" just makes me feel like it will be another survival sandbox game with some RPG elements.
You also can't have that much roleplaying depth with a procedurally generated world. There's only so much that we'll be able to do on RNG alone.
That's why the likes of STALKER and Subnautica stand up in my mind in terms of survival, exploration, and adventure. Hand-crafted worlds and quests are hard to beat.
Will the mountains be as boring as NMS?
No, these ones will be taller.
Fun fact: you can climb mountains that are miles high, taller than Everest already in no man’s sky. Is it fun? No it really isn’t.
Seems like Sean Murray went to the Peter Molyneux School of Videogame Marketing.
Ok, but will those mountains be littered by the dead? And also garbage?
Hey! It's not that simple! There's feces too.
Once I read a guy who got into an argument about that on Reddit.
The people there were upset at the idea that a bunch of crazies would just go there leaving literal trails of garbage behind them for a stupid challenge.
Basically the guy told them :
_ who cares, there's nothing alive at this altitude
_ it''s so extreme there is no way to attempt this in a clean way
_ even people who go there don't care about the vistas being ruined by shit, because they're too busy trying to stay alive
_ yes indeed, he wanted to do it himself one day and "you'd better believe I'll drop all my shit over the place"
So yeah, they believe it's okay to pollute a place for sports because that place is "useless" anyway. Or at least that's their excuse.
The rich assholes that climb everest and litter everywhere make a great metaphor for humanity at large
The army sherpas doing all the actual hard work behind the scenes really nails the metaphor.
Nope, I can't see any problem coming from this claim at all. It's not like they have a history of over promising and then under delivering or anything like that.
I should work in the games industry. Apparently you don't need to be very bright.
The comparison is moot. Most of us have never seen Everest. I mean even in their last game, I'm sure if they just pulled some world mesh above the clouds and made sure there was a path you could do the same Everest climb. We went to space without a loading screen lol
Every time I read about Everest, I can't not think about how the base camp is already higher than anything that exists in the alps
Crazy
Why?
Running straight up mountains mashing a jump button is fun, but it does get old after a few minutes. Not aure why you'd make a huge mountain.
I get the skepticism but I think that after they got humbled into providing free DLC for 7 years, they aren't going to make the same mistake. I'm cautiously optimistic in other words.
I'm not sure that's something I want. It takes days to climb Everest! I don't want to play for days just to climb a procedurally generated mountain that probably doesn't have anything on top of it. Or at best has some random shit that you can find everywhere else.
Why?
Not really selling it
And people looked at me funny saying I won't buy anything from them for the hype they built with NMS. And here it is, happening again. See you in 5 years when the game actually has the features, huh
But bro, you can climb mountains taller than the everest. Think of the possibilities, like climbing a mountain. Imagine looking up and seeing a mountain and then looking down and still seeing a mountain, but then you look left and right and you guessed it, still mountain.
I read this in Morty's voice and it was great.
Not my type of game but I think Hello Games has managed to redeem themselves somewhat. The amount of updates they churned out to meet NMS's promises and go above and beyond them is nuts.
Hopefully they learned their lesson from their first fuck up and won't torpedo whatever goodwill they've managed to win back.
view more: next ›