Movies and TV Shows

Theres a lot here and I dont have the time to tackle everything but I will say the movie isnt about making the atomic bomb, its about Oppenheimer and the complexities of the person who made the bomb because of his impact on history.

There only being silence when the bomb actually went off was the perfect way to depict the scene - Oppenheimer opened pandora's box and the focus is entirely on the person instead of the explosion. I thought it was a bold and intelligent creative choice precisely because it makes you engage with the inner workings of Oppy's mind and the central premise of the film. Making the dramatic tension about an explosion instead of what the movie is actually about is what would have came off as pretentious to me.

I think you can argue against the movie being pretentious in general because this isnt a work of fiction and Oppenheimer was incredibly important and influential and effected actual lives. Every little moment, quirk, or relationship molded him and created the person that literally changed the world. Folks can disagree on whether they have a positive or negative perception of Oppenheimer but to say the man and his life's depictions are unimportant or pretentious doesn't seem fair.

Personally I liked the test scene. I was tense waiting for the pressure wave to hit them

Seems to me like you were expecting a movie about the making of the atom bomb, when the movie was clearly focusing on the life of the man who created it.

I went with someone who's entire knowledge of Oppenheimer was the Epic Rap Battle video and they were perfectly able to follow the entire story and the multiple location and date changes.

I would like to hear more of your thoughts on why you thought the movie was pretentious.

As for the sound, in my theater everything sounded great, maybe just slightly too loud in some scenes. Could it be just a bad setup?

Finally, I did not find the Trinity test underwhelming in any way. However, I can understand why some people might. However this ties into my first point. The story is not really about the creation of the bomb, but how making it affected the man behind it. Could be just that didn't work for you while it did for me.

I found it to be a very "Nolan" film. All his usual flares like story told in rapid fire edits out of chronological order from different points in time, loud music and sound effects over dialog, etc. His movies can be heavy and hard to take in and the fact this one is three hours long makes hard to sit through in my opinion. I would still recommend it though. Amazing performances from an A tier roster of actors.

Right there with you, I share your sentiments about the film. I couldn’t hear half the dialogue because the music was so goddamn loud. And there was wall to wall music from frame 1. I counted maybe five short scenes were there wasn’t music. I couldn’t connect with the film and the characters because of it and it’s always the same problem in his films. Especially for the last three.

The movie's nonlinear story telling is the worst part of the film. Oppenheimer's security clearance hearing was a good place to anchor the movie, but it did not even attempt to set up its antagonist until the last quarter of the movie. Why should it have been a ah-ha moment that Strauss was against Oppenheimer. A better editor would have more effectively placed all of the scenes into a coherent narrative.

The sex scene was just bad. "Christopher, how do intelligent people have sex?" "Well, they can only be aroused by reading ancient languages that foreshadow their grandiose future achievements."

When Oppenheimer, allegedly poisoned Blackett's apple, it should have been a scene about his mental health issues at the time. Rather than a completely fabricated suspense scene. People who were aware of the incident questioned if it ever really happened. It would have been more impactful to have a scene where Oppenheimer meets with his analyst from that period. The movie decides to simply say that it happened and for some reason interjected Bohr.

The portrayals of characters was a highlight of the film. Most of the acting was great. It was, however, overly stuffed with high profile actors, which turned the film into a distracting cameo bingo game.

The physical and psychological aftermath of the atomic booms dropping on Hiroshima and Nagasaki was not adequately portrayed. It did not show well enough the psychological toll it took on the scientists on the project or portray the horrific physical toll it inflicted on the Japanese people. The slide reel scene not showing a single image of the attack was a poor choice. It demonstrates that Hollywood is completely ok with an R rating for showing nudity, but not for confronting people with the horrors of human cruelty.