I wouldn't like it. I felt like Threads wasn't going to interact much with Lemmy in the first place and it would've been a Mastodon-only problem. Extending it to have a "Reddit-like mode" will it make it significantly worse for us.
this post was submitted on 10 Jul 2023
2 points (58.3% liked)
Fediverse
17735 readers
50 users here now
A community dedicated to fediverse news and discussion.
Fediverse is a portmanteau of "federation" and "universe".
Getting started on Fediverse;
- What is the fediverse?
- Fediverse Platforms
- How to run your own community
founded 5 years ago
MODERATORS
aa
I feel the average person has no idea that we will lose this battle step by step. You guys have the right idea, but many just cant see the risk until after it happens.
The Lemmy.world admins wrote a whole post about this. https://lemmy.world/post/1274909
I don't see any relevance between your response and my post, can you explain what that link has to do with a possible v2 of threads.net that has a reddit style mode?
Your post is based on a supposition that doesn’t exist. It’s clickbait fear mongering with no basis in reality.
The post (and link) is admin confirmation that there is no “hypothetical v2”. Facebook’s Threads is no more likely to federate with Lemmy than Twitter is… or Reddit for that matter.
My response is a good faith attempt to talk about the possibility of them expanding in a realistic and likely direction. Your response is entirely bad faith. My title is about as boring as could be, not clickbait and hypotheticals don't need to be based in reality. Threads has also federated in(as in its in the instance whitelist), and my hypothetical was the part where they properly federate into lemmy, you are wrong on all account and are acting like a bot.
I’ll be honest, I’ll assume bad faith from Meta until proven otherwise.
A good example here is the first version of Google chat, which federated with jabber - until it didn’t. I was quite vocal about converting my friends to it because it was an easy entrance to jabber, with a brand and interface they trusted.
Then once it was big enough, jabber federation was cut off and we looked like the weird outsiders.
Federating Meta will feel like a win right up until it doesn’t.
You can follow Lemmy communities from Mastodon so I would assume it will also be possible from Threads if they federate with at least one Mastodon instance.
It's not a very Reddit-like experience. I tested it on Mastodon by following a community here and it just spammed my feed with out of context replies so I unfollowed it fairly quickly.
But that experience is likely to improve? And no doubt Meta would like to kill Reddit with the same stone that kills Twitter.
Turbulent times ahead.
For the record, it seems threads.net is added to the instance list of lemmy.world.
view more: next ›