Ask Lemmy

TV series adaptations. Because they have more time to cover more/all of the books aspects.

I’m begging for more miniseries. Good Omens is the perfect example of taking just enough time to tell the story correctly.

TV series. If it's good, I get to spend more time with it that way.

Depends a lot on the story complexity and pacing. The fact that a lot of adaptations are done poorly because they end up being someone else's story with only the veneer of the source material for name recognition, and that is true for both movies and tv/streaming series.

A fast paced novel like Hunt for Red October that is constantly moving the plot forward would feel stretched thin as a multi hour series. Thrillers often fall into the category, and so do short novels like Lord of the Flies. Even a series of books of these types this tend to be better as movies.

A slower paced book or book series is far better as a series, although fantasy often suffers from a lack of budget or falling into the TV adaption issues of adding content that doesn't really fit the source material to fill time. Not to mention a successful series can have be renewed and end up being a detriment to the source material after the source material runs out.

Overall the run time should match the source material pacing and content if it is a direct adaptation, and both formats introduce issues when that doesn't line up with common video lengths. I really like it when streaming series have different length episodes so that they can be the length needed to tell that part of the story!

Depends on what's being adapted. Some things benefit from a longer run time to cover all the good stuff, while other things benefit from a lot of the guff being cut and the story streamlined.

Depends what it's based on. It should have a similar runtime. So short story -> movie, book -> mini series. If it's like a series of 5 books I guess it can be a full TV show.

TV or miniseries gives much more time to explore everything. I'm surprised it's not more common.

TV series would be best most of the time for adaptations. Miniseries specifically.

I actually agree with some people here. I enjoy mini series the most. This restricts the writer to stay closer to the source without going excessively out of bound with their interpenetration, allows for better character arcs and world building, without being restricted to 2-3 hours and no cliffhangers to sell the next 20 seasons. I prefer the 1 hour long episodes and then 8 to 12 at most. No season 2 unless it's another finished season in on itself.

With streaming the way it is, I would stop the chopping up of stories and start telling them in a new way. Shows are longer now and the quality difference is minimal, so just film and tell the story. Sitcoms and the like I get doing episodes but I think it’s time to review how stories are dispensed visually

TV, I like to get all cozy like

TV series for stories I loved. (Preference for animation unless it's sci-fi)

Movies for stories I enjoyed.

I don't have a great deal of time anymore to just binge watch every show that comes across my table so I need to be more selective.

Miniseries. That way I can make a proper movie week.

I wish that in order to make a non-original piece of film, there was a lengthy process where the filmmakers had to prove they had something new to say and jump through a bunch of hoops so that 17 groups of people didn't remake the same fucking book every couple of decades.

I like original stories.

imagine If instead of writing stories, most authors just wrote somebody else's story with the same names, sequence of events, and swapped out car for a horse and buggy. because the guy isn't eccentric enough.

Depends. Is it a novel with a single entry? Is it a series of books with a lot of emphasis on world development? Is it an action video game franchise with little plot or lore? Or a video game franchise that prides itself on story? Is it set in the current world or in a wildly different fantasy/sci-fi setting?

In general, it's rare for an action videogame or book to convert well into a series because it requires lots of writing by writers who didn't invent the world and, vice versa, it's rare for a highly detailed fantasy world to work well in a movie because there's not enough time to do world building. Not saying it's impossible and there are great examples of both, but generally those are the ones that don't work out.

TV series / mini series.

Tokyo Vice.

I rest my case.

Depending on what it is, TV series. Specifically animated. The exception to the rule would be anime currently running. I was severely disappointed by the Boruto movie being a collection of episodes from the anime, once I figured it out.