this post was submitted on 14 Jan 2025
27 points (100.0% liked)
Books
4711 readers
7 users here now
A community for all things related to Books.
Rules
- Be Nice
Official Bingo Posts:
Related Communities
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Just finished the second book Shift and started the third, Dust, from Silo series. The first two were really good, long enough to dive deep into it and on that sweet level of being easy to read yet enough detail to keep it interesting.
My SO reads me stories in the evening and now we are going through LOTR, although I must say it's getting a bit cumbersome, being quite slow-paced book and all, so we'll probably give up and switch to something else soon.
We are reading buddies. I am at the same spot right now. I started because of the Show. And got for Christmas Shift and Dust. If you watch the show too, I would love to hear your opinion.
Nice to hear! Well I've quite liked the show so far (also started reading because of it), I think they've managed to make the series both similar and different enough from the book for both to be enjoyed as individual interpretations of the same story. I love that they haven't rushed with the show either, the whole setting/environment is so interesting (and well made) that it's worth spending time with. I love that in the books as well, the rhythm works well to me at least and I enjoy dwelling in the silo itself and its details. It's nice that the people in the series are more diverse than in the books, and characters have more depth (although Juliette, but the character feels more unilateral in the book as well than many of the others). Some sidetracks, like that Salvador Quinn thing, feel a bit strange/forced, but we'll see how that turns out! How do you like the show then?
I have similar feelings. I like that Walker is a woman, this was a realistic change and something I think makes the relationship between Walker and Juliet get to a deeper level. I like the color, the atmosphere. Juliet’s Character in the books shines in interactions with different people. But because she is so introverted and work focused, we only get it in Silo 17 and in book 3. I liked the first season better though.
::: spoiler Tap for spoiler The cuts are too fast. We switch between scenes too often. In season 2 I think having Lukas be shadow after he was send to the mines is unbelievable. I really enjoy to hate and love Sims. But is way of speaking, dialect is so off from the others, which makes it hard to believe since it is hinted and makes sense in the books that the Silos develop their own dialects. But English is not my first language so that could only be me. Will I watch season 3? Yes!
Have to agree on that, now that you mentioned! Sims kinda feels like he's from another world, his dialect is too distinctive from the others. It would've been nice to see/hear more silo-specific language being used, dialects and idioms, the books only mention it a few times as well!
I just watched the latest episode and can't wait to see how the next season turns out! IMDB says there should be a 4th season coming as well but it would be the last one.
There's a lot of fanfic based on the Silo world and I hear some of it very good. Somebody had linked this list of popular Silo fanfic on Reddit, The Karma series as well as Silo 42 and Silo 49 were recommended!