Asklemmy

I say this as someone who considers themselves a leftist....

The lack of civility shown by left leaning people online is almost certainly pushing moderates into more extreme communities and the unhinged takes are perfect meme fodder for those with a bad agenda. Instead of channeling your anger at the person you're corresponding with through your keyboard, channel it at a lack of empathy and understanding in society as a whole and respond with kindness and disengage when the conversation is not honest.

Repeat above for the use of "nazi". The use of the word has become devalued because people like to fling it at folks with milquetoast centrist opinions, save it for people who are legitimately evil.

This is political and only (if at all) interesting inside of your Usa with it's broken system

Is this definition of "leftists" widely accepted? I always thought that word was just another word for liberal or anyone who isn't right wing these days.

This could very well break this community's rule about being offensive and political discussions. I'll leave it open for now to see where it goes.

The perfect is the enemy of the good, and demanding a politico-savior will leave you wanting forever. Keeping your hands clean betrays your selfishness, not your commitment.

Violent revolution that results in a population moving left is so absurdly unlikely as to be dismissed, and any planning that depends on it mere daydream to salve frustration.

The liberal and the centrist who together elected a moderate in the face of a reactionary have done more to save you than all of your theory has done to save them.

And I wish none of that were true.

I think people to the left of Democratic Socialists need to start reading up on anarchy and anarchism. It's not about lawlessness and disorder but about horizontally focused civilization. It's about anti-authoritarianism.

Oooh as a communist... where to even start. Most of this is US/anglo centric...

1. Actually read fucking theory. Most of it was literally written for 19th century German factory workers with a third grade education who worked 16 hour shifts in the orphan crushing factory. When people say this it isn't because they want to feel smart, it's because you're saying dumb shit that got litigated out in like the '60s and you sound like a moron.
2. This does not include "video essays" on "breadtube." If I wanted something explained to me badly by a pedophile I'd join NAMBLA.
3. For the love of all that is holy, read something written after the second World War. Vast intellectual strides have been made in the past several decades. We do not need to relitigate the fucking Sino-Soviet split in the year of our Lord 2023. They both kinda fucking sucked. Read Debord. Read Tiqqun for all I care. But if I get handed one more Trotskyist zine I'm gonna fucking lose it.
4. Any modern communist party, especially in the imperial core, is probably dogshit. The IMT are sex abusers, PSL has terrible politics, and I'm not even gonna touch the western Maoists.
5. We are not in an era of resurgence for the Left. Comparing the intellectual and political influence of the Left in e.g. the '70s vs today is straight up depressing. The average SNCC/BPP member could run circles around 90% of Twitter "Leftists" while ripping a fat joint of the worst dirt weed known to man.
6. Anti-intellectualism is an extremely bad look. We should seek to deeply understand as much of the world as possible, not fall back on misunderstanding and anecdotes. That isn't to say that the modern state of academia isn't godawful, but forming opinions off screenshots of headlines does not lead to a coherent worldview.
7. For anarchists especially: stop fetishizing mob violence. "Death penalty without trial for alleged rapists!" is not a progressive opinion, and will give free reign to the worst elements in society.
8. Horizontal organization is not a panacea for State repression. While the BLM protests would have been more immune to COINTELPRO than was the BPP, it was dead easy for the government to shut them down through standard curfews and kettling because the whole thing was so goddamn disorganized.
9. While deplatforming is often effective as a tactic, it can easily be turned around on the Left. Big business is only your friend so long as it's profitable, and will kick you off as soon as an advertiser complains about anti-landlord discrimination or some dumb shit.
10. Opposition to technology is also not a progressive viewpoint. It is important to separate a given technology from who owns it. Computing can be used to democratize production and allocate resources – the fact that it is primarily used to further the aims of the capitalist class is an implementation detail of the present economic system. Personally, I'm gonna keep taking aspirin even though it's manufactured by Big Pharma.
11. "Shrill panic" is not a good tone, especially when your understanding of the facts is limited. Would Fred Hampton have had a meltdown on main because some junior state senator in Idaho proposed a piece of legislation that was clearly never going to make it to a vote? No? Ok so shut the fuck up then.
12. US pigs are terrible, but that isn't a unique phenomenon. "Of course the French can protest that good, they don't have US police!" sir the French police literally love beating protestors to within an inch of their life, you sound like an idiot.
13. It's not enough to say "thing sucks." You have to come up with something better. And that's often fucking hard, but incredibly worthwhile.

I truly do have optimism that we can build a better world. Every once in a while, it shines through the cracks: kids partying in the street while cops look on powerless, a little old lady cheering from the window while marchers chant "fuck 12," even a single trans person finding a community that accepts them wholeheartedly.

But damn do you internet mfs make it hard sometimes.

Sometimes you have to fucking do something. We can't make big changes overnight. Start small. Organize soup kitchens in your community. Or a community garden. Or start holding party meetings and recruiting people to the cause. And stop making excuses for "leftist" murderers just because they're "leftist".

They need to know that the system can only be changed from within. Being apathetic or edgy does not change anything. Voting does.

If there's is no one to vote for? Well, the parties too can only be changed from within. Join a party and vote in that party for it to change it's direction.

I’ll quote Steely Dan here: “Unhand that gun, begone. There’s no one to fire upon.”

As infuriating and frustrating it is to live in a world plagued with systemic issues, it’s important to recognize that many of the world’s problems can’t be traced back to a single person, government, organization, or ideology. Some things are just nobody’s fault, and can’t be solved be a mere change of leadership.

Every society in the world today, no matter how it is structured or who it is lead by, will be subject to a list of inevitable problems. Scarcity. Bigotry. Violence. Crime. Incompetence. Selfishness. The uncomfortable fact is that nobody knows how to structure a society such so that all citizens meet their basic needs in exchange for an amount of work that they find tolerable.

This is true of the United States, of Europe, of the Soviet Union, of China under the CCP, and of every other country to ever exist. Some countries are, of course, worse than others. But in many countries you find that people and politicians try in earnest to improve society and simply fall short, sometimes because they misidentify the core issues, and other times because they don’t have good enough ideas for solving them.

I encourage everyone to look at politics as groups of impassioned people with strong opinions about how their lives might be improved. At the end of the day, those of us with kind hearts are trying our best to defeat a common enemy, and merely differ in approach. I think a lot of people would do good to realize that.

The leftists have become a corpo/billionaires shills since occupy wall street happened.

Since 2012 the left ceased to exist in the mainstream. Class issues that the left raised before the takeover ware replaced by identity politics. Labels were introduced and Massed Formation Psychosis was initiated. All dissidents of even a slightly different opinion were attacked/cancelled en masse. Freedom of speech, religion, was now seen as archaic, nuclear families were seen as dangerous, racism and segregation were accepted ect.

Psychosis reached it's peak in 2020 when people had more time to reflect on their views in their time of isolation from coronavirus and subsequently more and more people were coming to their senses.

The scales are starting to swing back but in my opinion due to the sheer momentum of people waking up this will have catastrophic consequences for the western civilization.

Currently still there are no sensible/uncompromised leftist movements left and the only alternatives are on the right. And, like I said above, this will have catastrophic consequences.

I'd be interested to hear where communism, socialism, or any far left government has ever worked in the real world.

Because there are plenty of examples of it being a nightmare.

As much as we get along on conversation and political theory, I actually hate your ideology. We get along because we agree that a strong government is needed. We disagree because I need it to protect my freedoms, you need it to control the economy.

• A Left Libertarian